Accidents and Injuries Happen… They Get Resolved Here.TM
Close this search box.
Accidents and Injuries Happen…
They Get Resolved Here.
Close this search box.

Call us now

(780) 760-4878 (HURT)

Written by Joseph A. Nagy, Edmonton Injury Lawyer

TMD Is Not a Minor Injury

TMD Is Not a Minor Injury Subject to the Minor Injury Regulation

In Sparrowhawk v Zapoltinski (2012) A.J. No. 54(Q.B.)(Q.L.), an insurance company argued that Temporomandibular Joint Dysfunction was subject to the Minor Injury Regulation, with the conclusion being that any TMD injury was “capped.” For this to be true, the TMD had to be classified as a “sprain, strain or whiplash associated disorder” to a “muscle, tendon, or ligament.”  In this decision, the Court writes:

A. The Injury is Not a Sprain, Strain, or WAD

90    Dr. Thomas concluded that Mr. Sparrowhawk’s jaw injury more likely than not involved damage to the TMJ’s cartilage. A cartilage was described by the experts as a kind of tissue found in joints that assists in the smooth movement of body parts through that joint’s axis or axes of rotation. As previously explained, I preferred Dr. Thomas’ evidence on the involvement of cartilage injury in Mr. Sparrowhawk’s jaw dysfunction.

91    The experts agreed that a cartilage is not a muscle, tendon, or ligament. Injury to the cartilage is therefore not a “sprain” or “strain”: MIR, s. 1, DTPR, s. 1.

92    Similarly, the experts agreed that TMD is not a facet of WAD; that point was conceded by the parties. Even if that point had been disputed I would conclude that the exclusion of “jaw pain” from WAD I and WAD II symptoms by DTPR, ss. 17(a)(vi)(E), 20(a)(vi)(E) meant that the WAD injuries do not include the jaw.

93    I also concluded that Mr. Sparrowhawk experienced a non-minor injury as the TMD caused anomalous wear and damage to his teeth. Dr. Thomas concluded, and I agree, that the bruxofacets visible on Mr. Sparrowhawk’s teeth are a direct consequence of his TMD injury. That injury caused anomalous jaw movement and grinding. Mr. Sparrowhawk’s pre-injury dental records show no signs of that kind of anomalous tooth wear.

94    As teeth are not muscle, tendon, or ligaments, I conclude the bruxofaceting is also not a “sprain” or “strain”, nor is it a WAD injury.

95    On these bases I conclude that Mr. Sparrowhawk’s jaw injuries are not minor injuries.

It is important to remember that the Minor Injury Regulation applies to “sprains, strains, and whiplash associated disorders to muscles, tendons, or ligaments.” This statement is the starting point for any analysis that your injuries are “capped.” Any other injuries are arguably not capped. Sometimes you may not recognize the full extent of your injuries. It is not unusual for a patient or client to present themselves to their doctors or their lawyer with injuries and symptoms that they do not understand or that their doctor won’t diagnose. A professional injury lawyer is very experienced in this area.

Joseph A. Nagy,
Edmonton Injury Lawyer
Joseph A. Nagy Injury Law, Edmonton Injury Lawyer

Joseph A. Nagy is an experienced Edmonton personal injury lawyer. Joe provides injury law services to people who have been injured in motor vehicle accidents in Edmonton and throughout Central and Northern Alberta. Joe has successfully resolved thousands of personal injury cases. If you have suffered a personal injury and need the help of a proven, experienced personal injury lawyer, contact Joseph A. Nagy Injury Law. Ask Joe for a free consultation. 

Recent Posts

AllInjury Law

What Is No-Fault Insurance?

March 2, 2023

Joseph A. Nagy Injury Law opposes the introduction of any further cap,...


To Stop a Thief – What Could Go Wrong?

February 14, 2023

An SEF 44 is a separate contract rider on your own insurance...


Patel v Certas Direct Insurance Co., [2020] A.J. No. 793

August 31, 2020

In light of Patel v Certas, Edmonton injury lawyer Joseph A, Nagy...


A Summary of the Law on Section 581 Advances

August 14, 2020

Edmonton injury lawyer Joseph A. Nagy summarizes the importance of recent case...


Choosing an Alberta Injury Lawyer

April 22, 2019

New injury law firms are continuously entering the Alberta market. But does...


Serious Impairment II – Updated

June 1, 2018

Injury lawyer Joseph A. Nagy discusses McLean v Parmar, 2015 ABQB 62...

Scroll to Top

Edmonton Injury Lawyer
Free Consultation



Personal Injury Glossary Comments